I have just crowded round a computer screen with my colleagues to watch Australia’s new Prime Minister, Kevin Rudd, make an historic speech in Parliament. The word ‘historic’ is over-used, but this time it is genuinely warranted I think.

Or is it? I’m not sure how I feel about this speech, to be honest.

Is it just words? And if it is, is that neccessarily a bad thing? Words can be powerful.

He said “Sorry” to the Stolen Generations on behalf of the government, parliament and non-indigenous people of Australia for the pain and suffering caused by the removal of children from their families by state and religious officials over a period of a hundred years.

A hundred years!

I can’t even imagine what that must do to a community.

Anyway, it was a good speech, eloquent and sincere, and it did not mince words. Mr Rudd ended positively, looking to a future of reconciliation and cross-party co-operation to improve opportunites for indigenous Australians.

[One example of the inequality: there is a 17 year difference in life expectancy between indigenous and non-indigenous Australians.]

As a foreigner here – particularly one from a country and continent which not only has a long history of institutional racism and colonialism by cannon but whose own government’s policies and whose own people’s beliefs were the root of the legislation here – I wonder what the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to whom the apology is addressed will make of it.

My Australian colleagues by and large seem to feel relieved that the apology has finally been made, although understandably uncomfortable being reminded of something for which they are collectively held responsible, despite the fact that many of their families were not actually in Australia between 1869 and 1969. An apology implies guilt, after all.

Yet, as in any relationship, its all very well saying sorry; what are we actually going to do to change things for the better? There seem to have been any number of well-intentioned and well-funded schemes in recent years aimed at improving education, healthcare and housing in indigenous communities. Most seem to have met with a fairly spectacular lack of success.

I don’t know anywhere near enough about the issue to venture an opinion on why they might have been unsuccessful. I don’t know any indigenous Australians and have never even visited an indigenous community.

So how is a country supposed to reconcile two very different communities into one nation when it doesn’t know how to tackle the basic problems which perpetuate those differences?

Are we misguided in attempting to make us all ‘the same’. Isn’t difference okay? Can it be a choice – our society and culture or theirs?

Saying sorry is hard, but changing one’s behaviour to avoid having to say sorry again in the future is the really tricky bit.

This entry was posted in oh I don't know, just stuff and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Sorry

  1. I am living and working in an indigenous community and I don’t know the answer to the problem. The indigenous population is so dysfunctuional and the bureaucratic solutions are so – bureaucratic – that the two rarely meet. A lot of the money being thrown at the problem (2 billion a year I believe).

    I can only speak for the remote areas but here everything is seen as “buckets of money” – this bucket for this, that bucket for that – and, being hunters and gatherers by culture (the area I am in has people who are still active who did not see a white man until they were grown-ups!) these “buckets of money” are simply another resource to be hunted and gathered. Until the bureaucracy truly understands this, and until we can convince the indigenous people that bad things can be prevented from happening and are not just “bad luck” little true progress will be made.

    I could go on and on but the whole situation makes me so sad!

  2. jennyincanada says:

    I like your last sentence …it’s one thing to speak the words, but the actions are what count most.

    I’ve started blogging again. I thought it would be nice to be able to start some sort of a “diary” type thing to look back on. I’m on my own this time. I’ll try and think of something interesting to write in the next couple of days!


  3. truce says:

    Thanks for the insight Archie, I knew from your blog that you were somewhere “out there” where the challenge confronts you on a daily basis. Interesting point about the bad things being seen as just bad luck, rather than actions/events which could be prevented, I hadn’t thought of that but of course it makes perfect sense as part of the indigenous culture. Judging by what my Granny used to say, it would be equally valid as part of the very religious culture of rural Ireland (where she grew up) until quite recently, too. Maybe it has to do with seeing god or the gods as responsible for fate, rather than individuals controlling their own destinies?

    Thanks Anish! I’ll try 🙂

    Hey Jenny, good to have you back and very glad to hear you’ll be blogging again. I’ll be right over…

  4. truce says:

    Oh hang on, where’s the link to your blog?… 😦

  5. jennyincanada says:

    Oops .. did it work this time?

    Just in case:

  6. truce says:

    Yay! Found it 🙂

  7. Words are nice, apologies are good. But how does a speech mitigate a century of neglect and abuse?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s